The Murder Is Not the Real Story
There is an immediate complication with Lynda La Plante’s The Governor. It is arriving on shelves as a 2026 release, but it is not a new novel.
The Governor is being released again as a fully revised and edited edition, but readers could easily miss just how far back the story goes.
The novel was originally published in 1995, alongside La Plante’s television drama of the same period. That matters, particularly if, like me, you begin reading with the nagging feeling that you have encountered some of this before.
The fact that it is a revised edition is acknowledged in some promotional material, but the original 1995 publication date is far less obvious. That distinction should be clearer when a book is being presented to readers as a current release.
It does not make the new edition unwelcome. But it is useful to know what you are buying.
The bigger surprise comes once the story gets underway.
On the surface, The Governor is a crime novel. Helen Hewitt becomes the youngest female governor of Barfield, a troubled high-security men’s prison, following a riot and a suspicious death.
There is corruption to uncover, drugs moving through the prison, officers whose loyalties are questionable and inmates who understand the institution considerably better than the people supposedly running it.
Yet the murder gradually becomes less interesting than Hewitt herself.
This is really a book about what it means to take responsibility for an institution that is already in trouble.
Hewitt has the job title, but authority proves considerably harder to establish. She must work out who can be trusted, which rules are genuinely being followed and which have simply become part of the mythology of the place. Every attempt to change something creates another problem somewhere else.
That is where the novel is strongest.
La Plante gives the prison an uncomfortable internal logic. Officers, prisoners and management all have different interests, and nobody operates in isolation. Hewitt cannot simply arrive, identify the bad actors and put everything right. She has budgets, damaged facilities, staff resistance, political expectations and a prison population capable of exploiting every weakness.
Reading it three decades after its original publication, that part has aged surprisingly well. Some of the attitudes have not.
The reaction to a young woman taking control of a male prison firmly locates the novel in another period, even allowing for the fact that resistance to Hewitt is central to the plot. There are moments when the gender politics feel more heavily signposted than they might be in a contemporary novel.
The structure can also feel like its television origins are showing.
At 560 pages, The Governor is not particularly lean. Problems arrive one after another, and the novel sometimes moves more like a continuing drama than a thriller driving relentlessly towards the solution of a single crime.
Readers waiting for the murder investigation to dominate may wonder when the book is going to get back to it. But that may be asking the wrong question.
Once Hewitt’s struggle to control Barfield becomes the main event, the wider structure makes more sense. The drugs, violence, staff behaviour, politics and individual crises are not distractions from the story. Collectively, they are the story.
There is also an unanswered question around the new edition itself. It is described as fully revised and edited, but there is little readily available explanation of exactly what has changed from the 1995 version.
Without comparing the editions side by side, it is impossible to know how extensive that revision has been. Given the prominence of the new release, greater clarity would have been useful.
None of that takes away from La Plante’s ability to keep the institution tense and unpredictable. The appeal of The Governor lies less in discovering who did what than in learning how Hewitt discovers just how little control a governor can have over the prison she is supposed to run.
That makes this a slightly different book from the one its crime-thriller packaging might suggest.
If you come to The Governor expecting a new Lynda La Plante murder mystery, there are two things worth knowing. It is a revised return to a novel first published more than 30 years ago, and the murder is not actually the most compelling part of it.
The governor is.
OUR RATING – 3/5
More from the FENNEC Book Club here
