Are you sweet but secretly sassy? A bold leader who can’t resist stirring up drama? Or maybe the queen of comfort and calm—but only until the next scandal breaks? Find out which cast member’s Dirty Soda order best captures your vibe with this fun personality breakdown. Ready to sip and spill the tea?
1. Taylor Frankie Paul (@taylorfrankiepaul) – “The Bubbly Coconut Chiller”
Personality Type: You’re the group motivator and often the first to jump into a new adventure—whether it’s a last-minute road trip or the next big online trend. Friends rely on you for your high-energy spirit and fearless attitude. You love taking charge, but don’t be surprised if your confident moves occasionally spark a bit of “friendly” competition (or controversy).
- Base Soda: Classic cola
- Mix-Ins: Coconut cream + splash of pineapple juice
- Finishing Touch: A drizzle of heavy cream with a sliced lime garnish
- Flavour Vibe: Bold and energising—just like Taylor, who’s always ready to lead the pack into mischief or mop up the aftermath.
2. Demi Engemann (@demilucymay_) – “The Fierce & Fruity”
Personality Type: You’re equal parts sugar and spice, perfectly blending a sweet exterior with a hint of sass. Everyone knows you as the lively spirit who keeps things interesting, offering playful banter one moment and heartfelt support the next. You’re the friend who organizes spontaneous get-togethers—just watch out if someone crosses you, because that spark can become a flame real quick.
- Base Soda: Lemon-lime soda
- Mix-Ins: Raspberry purée and a squirt of lime juice
- Finishing Touch: Whipped cream swirled on top with a sprinkle of freeze-dried raspberries
- Flavour Vibe: Fresh and tangy—Demi’s perfect pick for balancing sweetness and sass whenever #MomTok drama bubbles up.
3. Jen Affleck (@jenniferaffleckk) – “The Smooth Operator”
Personality Type: Calm and collected, you bring a sense of stability to your circle. You’re the go-to for advice when your friends are stuck in a swirling rumour mill—yet you still maintain an air of quiet mystery that leaves people curious. You prefer to solve problems behind the scenes, keeping the peace while ensuring that everyone around you feels validated and heard.
- Base Soda: Vanilla cola
- Mix-Ins: Caramel syrup + coconut-flavoured syrup
- Finishing Touch: A delicate layer of half-and-half and a caramel drizzle
- Flavour Vibe: Warm and comforting, with just enough flair to keep things interesting. This is the go-to drink for Jen’s quieter, but quietly powerful, presence.
4. Jessi Ngatikaura (@_justjessiiii) – “The Tropical Tease”
Personality Type: Easygoing and upbeat, you can charm just about anyone with your breezy sense of humor and magnetic presence. Optimistic by nature, you believe that even the worst conflicts can be talked through (or laughed through). You’re the friend everyone calls when they want to shake off stress with a fun night out or a heartfelt pep talk—and you’re more than happy to deliver both.
- Base Soda: Sparkling water (for a lighter, refreshing fizz)
- Mix-Ins: Passion fruit syrup + splash of mango juice
- Finishing Touch: Layer of coconut cream drizzled on top with a decorative umbrella
- Flavour Vibe: Bright and breezy, matching Jessi’s upbeat social feed—until the gossip hits, that is.
5. Layla Taylor (@laylaleannetaylor) – “The Zesty Punch”
Personality Type: Real talk is your middle name. You’re unafraid to call out drama, and though your honesty can be shocking, it’s refreshing in a world full of sugarcoating. People trust you because you don’t mince words—if there’s a problem, you’d rather address it head-on than let it simmer. Deep down, though, you also have a nurturing side that balances out your straight-shooting nature.
- Base Soda: Ginger ale
- Mix-Ins: Pomegranate juice + lime zest
- Finishing Touch: A swirl of vanilla creamer with crushed candy pieces on top
- Flavour Vibe: Refreshing and a bit sharp—reflecting Layla’s tendency to keep it real and call out the drama.
6. Mayci Neeley (@maycineeley) – “The Sweetheart Smash”
Personality Type: With a soft heart and genuine warmth, you’re the quintessential sweetheart. Friends often come to you for comfort, giggles, and a much-needed mood boost. You thrive on spreading positivity but can get caught in the crossfire when bigger personalities clash around you. While you prefer to keep the peace, you can step up and hold your own if pushed too far.
- Base Soda: Cream soda
- Mix-Ins: Strawberry purée + a teaspoon of rose syrup
- Finishing Touch: Dollop of whipped cream with heart-shaped sprinkles
- Flavour Vibe: Soft, sweet, and pretty—just like Mayci’s aesthetic. But don’t underestimate her, because just beneath that sugary exterior lies a knack for stirring the pot.
7. Mikayla Matthews (@mikaylamatthews) – “The Mocha Mixer”
Personality Type: You’re a bit of a night owl, fueled by ambition and a flair for the dramatic. When you go after your goals, you do it with style—think confidence, creativity, and a dash of boldness that sets you apart. People might underestimate you at first, but one sip of your quick wit and unique energy, and they’ll realize you’re serious about making things happen.
- Base Soda: Cola (or Diet Cola)
- Mix-Ins: A splash of cold brew concentrate + chocolate syrup
- Finishing Touch: Cream swirl dusted with cocoa powder
- Flavour Vibe: Rich and indulgent—perfectly matching Mikayla’s love for a little flair and her flair for dramatic moments.
8. Whitney Leavitt (@whitneyleavitt) – “The Luxe Lavender Twist”
Personality Type: Classy and composed, you love introducing a dash of elegance to every situation—whether it’s hosting an upscale brunch or planning the perfect Instagram-worthy moment. You’re the friend who creates calm in the middle of a storm. But don’t let that poise fool anyone into thinking you can’t handle drama; you’re fully capable of stepping in to restore harmony when necessary.
- Base Soda: Club soda (or sparkling water)
- Mix-Ins: Lavender syrup + lemon juice
- Finishing Touch: Frothy half-and-half poured gently on top with a lavender bud garnish
- Flavour Vibe: Light, floral, and undeniably chic—a reflection of Whitney’s polished approach to both social media and defusing real-life showdowns.
Take a Sip of Your True Self
Whichever Dirty Soda speaks to you, it’s time to whip one up and settle in for a delicious binge of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. After all, everyone needs a signature drink to match their personality—especially when the next scandal lurks just around the corner. So pop open your favourite soda, swirl in those sweet add-ons, and toast to another season of jaw-dropping #MomTok drama! Available on Disney+ on May 15!
